← Blog
Psychology

Why goal setting doesn't work and what to set instead of yearly goals

Yearly goals are written by someone you will no longer be in a year
Igor Graf · November 20, 2026 · 14 min

Look at what people write on their yearly goal list in December: a bag, a car, a trip to the States, "pay off debt", "save my relationship". By spring, a list like that usually leaves behind nothing but guilt. I have not set yearly goals since 2019. For the year I have a vision, and my goals are short.

Why doesn't goal setting work? Because the list usually holds things that cannot work as goals. Goals stop working in three cases:

  1. The list is full of wishes to "have" something.
  2. The goal is set for a year and nobody looks at it again until December.
  3. The goal belongs to someone else, or it sounds like running away from something bad: "get out of debt", "save my relationship".

The fix is short goals, for a month, a quarter, sometimes one week, and a vision for the year and beyond: a direction and an image of who you are becoming. A car or a trip is a reward for the distance covered, so it belongs on a wish list.

I have been in business for twenty years, fourteen of them teaching entrepreneurs, and I have run more than 2,000 in-depth interviews. The question "is it even right to set goals" comes most often from people who have set them several times and never arrived. Willpower will not fix it here, because the person is asking a goal to do work it cannot do. Below I cover what work a goal can do and what a vision does, where the research disagrees with me, and what to set in December instead of a list for the year.

Why goal setting doesn't work: people write wishes on their goal list

I separate three different things that usually get thrown into one pile, and most failures with goal setting grow out of that confusion. I recorded a separate video about it, a walk through Los Angeles, and it is short.

Vision is an image and a direction for the next two or three years and beyond. You never reach it, the same way you never reach the horizon: however far you walk, you still see five kilometers (about three miles) further. A vision is there so that every day you can drop whatever does not lead toward it.

A goal is a specific result with a deadline, one you can measure and one that brings you closer to the vision. You can forecast it: you understand what to do and roughly how long it will take.

A wish is what you will get, physically and emotionally, when you arrive: a car, a down payment on an apartment, a ski trip. It does not go into goals, because it is a reward, and a wish solves no problem.

Three different thingsVision2–3 years and beyonda direction, like the horizonGoala month, a quarterdeadline, measurable resultWishat the checkpointa reward for the distanceIgor Graf's model: goals intensive 2020, video 2025
Most goal-setting failures come from writing these three things on one list.

A simple example. Vision about health: I am seventy, I carry my grandchildren on my back without effort, nothing hurts. Goal: I have gastritis now and I want to cure it in two months. Wish: when I close this goal, I go skiing. If you write "be healthy" among your December goals, the pressure comes from every side, because it can be neither measured nor finished. If you write "go to the mountains", you will go anyway, it is only a matter of time, and a goal like that will not stretch you.

VisionGoalWish
Time frame2–3 years and beyond, never endsa month, a quarter, sometimes a weekdoes not matter
Questionwhere am I going and who am I becomingwhat exactly do I do nowwhat do I get when I arrive
Example"I am proud of the team I built""hire the first manager by the end of the month""a trip to the US"
Where it livesin front of your eyes, checked against every decisionin the monthly planon the wish map, next to the checkpoints
What happens if you set it as a goalit presses on you and feels unreachableit worksit loses value and stops giving energy

In December 2020, after an intensive on goals, I gave the participants a rule: do not put a vision or a wish into your goals, least of all into goals for the year. If you do, they most likely will not come true, and your state will get worse on top of that. I see the second part all the time: once you turn a wish into a plan, it stops being fun and starts hanging over you like a debt.

Here is what a typical December list looks like when you sort it into columns.

Item from the "goals for the year" listWhere it actually belongs
Earn $10,000 a monthvision (lifestyle); the goal is the breakdown: sales, deals, negotiations for this month
Buy a cara wish, a reward for a checkpoint
Lose 10 kg (22 lb)a goal, if you have a method and a 2–3 month deadline
Move to Spainvision, a direction
Pay off debtrunning away from something bad, rephrase it as a step forward
Launch my own coursea goal, if you break it down to "hold 10 conversations with clients this month"

Goals vs systems: why "having" goals drain you

The short answer to "goals or systems" is both, but you have to like the process. A goal gives the direction of the next step, and you will walk every day only along a process that does not torture you. All wishes fall into three kinds: to be, to do, and to have. Ask a room what stands first on people's goal lists and it is almost always "have": money, an apartment, a body. "Do" comes less often, and "be", meaning who I want to become, almost never.

Wanting to have something is fine, but the cause and effect chain breaks. Say I want a beautiful body. To have it, I will have to do things: go on a diet, go to the gym three times a week. That means my way of being changes, my daily routine. Do I like the life of a sporty person? No, I like the life of an ice-cream eater. A goal to "have" starts a process in which I have to become someone else, and the whole road stops being fun. What remains is discipline, challenges and dares, and in the third week of chicken breast the person breaks down.

Have, Do, BeHow people set goalsHaveDoBeFirst the body or the number, then the diet and the 'must'. Burnout by week three.How it worksBeDoHaveYou enjoy the process → you do it daily → the result follows.
A 'have' goal asks you to become someone else. If you hate that path, only discipline is left.

If instead I find a sport I am truly interested in, tennis, running, football, a healthy body arrives as a side effect. That is how I dropped from 115 to 81 kilograms (about 254 to 179 pounds), and I tell that story in detail in the article why I can't achieve my goals. Business works the same way. If I only want to have money, every task and every problem of the business is a test for me, and I never wake up thinking "today is a great chance to get some work done". People who became entrepreneurs by way of being do not go back to a job, they simply no longer think that way.

Science agrees with me here. In 1999 Kennon Sheldon and Andrew Elliot followed how people pursue their goals across three samples and showed two things. Goals that fit a person's own interests and values get pursued harder and reached more often. And reaching such goals raises well-being more than reaching goals set under a "should" or for someone else's approval. In my words: a goal works when you like the road to it, and a goal that is not yours brings less joy even when you reach it.

Goals gone wild: what the research says

I will start with what works against my own thesis. Edwin Locke and Gary Latham, in a review of 35 years of research, showed that specific, difficult goals consistently produce better results than a vague "I'll do my best". A distant goal also works if you break it into near subgoals. Albert Bandura and Dale Schunk checked this back in 1981: children who struggled with math made fast progress with near subgoals, mastered the material and became interested in it, while a single distant goal helped noticeably less. So a yearly goal that you break down again every month does work, according to the research.

I agree with this, and it is exactly my scheme: a vision on top, short goals under it. There is one difference. In my scheme the far point has no number and no deadline, so when you change, you can change it without guilt. A yearly goal, on the other hand, gets written in January and is left untouched until December, and I see that in most of the people who come to me after a failed year.

Now the other side of the argument. In 2009 Lisa Ordóñez of the University of Arizona, with colleagues from Wharton, Northwestern and Harvard, published a paper called "Goals Gone Wild". Their conclusion: the benefits of goal setting are overstated and the systematic harm is ignored. Narrow, overly ambitious goals shrink your focus, push you toward unjustified risk and unethical decisions, damage culture and reduce intrinsic motivation.

The best known example from that paper is the Ford Pinto. Under a goal of "under 2,000 pounds and under $2,000 by 1970", engineers skipped safety checks, and the fuel tank could explode in a rear-end collision. The authors write that goals should be prescribed in measured doses, like medicine, and that goals aimed at learning and mastery give more, in both results and intrinsic motivation, than goals aimed at a number.

Goals in research1981Bandura & Schunkproximal subgoals work2002Locke & Lathamhard, specific goals2009Ordóñez et al.side effects of goalsJPSP 1981 · American Psychologist 2002 · Academy of Management Perspectives 2009
Science is for goals, short and self-chosen ones, and wary of narrow metrics.

In the same year Locke and Latham replied with a harsh paper saying the critics had picked convenient examples. The argument is still going, but both sides agree on one thing: a goal is a powerful tool with side effects, and you have to set it with care. James Clear, the author of Atomic Habits, adds one more argument: winners and losers have the same goals, we just do not see the ones who did not arrive. In his words, goals are good for setting a direction, and systems are what move you forward.

What Clear calls a direction, I call a vision. I part ways with him on one point: without a short measurable goal, a system falls apart for most people, and they spend years "working on themselves" without a single step you could check.

Should you stop setting yearly goals?

For the year you set a vision. I have not set yearly goals for myself since 2019 and I do not advise them to clients. The reason is simple: nobody knows what will happen to us in a year. I am not even talking about the economy, I am talking about you. You may become a different person, and goals set a year ago will no longer be needed. Over a one-year horizon two things break: there is no feedback for months, and the guilt of "did not get there" keeps piling up, even though you no longer want to get there.

A separate note on business, because people always ask: "What about the annual sales plan? The budget?" A company's annual financial plan is a forecast and a budget. You calculate it, and its numbers come from a breakdown: how many sales, how many deals, how many negotiations. It should be recalculated every quarter. A goal in the sense of this article is a promise to yourself, and that is the thing you should not give for a year.

There is one exception, and people rightly ask about it. In October 2025 my passive income burned down, I had $700 left on my card, and I publicly set a goal to make a million dollars from zero. The million works there as a vision and as public discipline; I wrote at the time that I started the blog as a discipline for myself. I move toward it in short steps, and each step can be checked.

How you enter a new year depends heavily on what the last one was like. I distinguish three modes, and each one needs its own approach to goals.

The "ass-deep" mode. The speed at which you are falling is higher than the speed at which you are climbing: debts press on you, a project is collapsing, relationships are going down the drain. Here you cannot set a goal on the principle of "get out of the hole". If you have tried setting "save my relationship" or "pay off $10,000 of debt", you felt it did not work: things only got worse, and there was no energy for it. What to set: one small step forward that lights you up, for example one new sale this week. The debts close as a side effect.

The "wow" mode. The year was very strong, for example you grew eight times, and now you want to "grow eight times again". Goals like that most often lead to a failure the following year, and after it to a year lived again in the "ass-deep" mode. What to set: a goal about the system, meaning strengthen what has grown, the team, the processes, your health, with no new "challenge" and no "next level".

The "comfort" mode. Everything seems fine, but something will not let go. There is no big growth, the ceiling does not break, nothing motivates you. You have a picture of how you will live at the top, but the route is a complete abstraction: you know you want to walk to Paris, but you do not know what to see on the way, it is a long walk, and your brain keeps pulling you to stay put, since it is not bad here either. If goals in "comfort" are set wrong, the person digs himself a hole in order to climb out of it heroically later, and every year starts to look like a roller coaster. What to set: a new direction and a small step into the unknown, a task you have never solved before.

Three modes of the yearAss-deepfalling faster than rising✕ don't set'climb out of the hole''pay off the debt'✓ setone step forwardthat lights you upWowyou grew several times✕ don't set'×8 again''next level'✓ seta goal for the system:team, processesComfortfine, but restless✕ don't setan abstract summitwith no route✓ seta new directionand a step into the unknownFrom the goals intensive summary, December 2020
How you set goals depends on what last year was like.

Living without goals: is it possible

You can live without yearly goals, but not without direction. In terms of the path, life has two states: when you are moving toward goals and when you are fully here and now. Trouble starts when these two processes are split apart.

If you have only goals and no ability to enjoy the moment, you live in constant stress: whatever goal you reach, there is always something higher, stronger, faster. If you have only "here and now", something like "I am in Phuket, everything is fine", then over time you will feel that you are not developing and you will fall into the comfort trap. If you have neither a goal nor the ability to enjoy what you have, a person spirals down. The resourceful state appears when you know where you are going and can still be grateful for what you already have.

Goals and the here and now1Stressgoals, but no joyin what you havethere is always higher2Comfort traponly the here and now,no direction'I'm in Phuket'3Downward spiralneither goalsnor gratitudeenergy drains4Resourceyou know where you goand value what you havethe only one that works
The resource state shows up when direction and gratitude for what you have live together.

There is one more reason you cannot live with no direction at all. People have a need for adventure, and nobody can do the same tasks for long. Something new appears when you set a direction and start solving a problem you have not solved before. Without a direction, the need for growth does not go anywhere, and the person starts creating problems on his own just to feel it again.

Goal vs dream: what's the difference

A dream is closest to a vision, so there is no point in setting it as a goal. In my program for experts and entrepreneurs I play a simple game with the participants. A participant is sitting in Petersburg, and I say: "Let's set a goal to walk to Lisbon. How long will you need?" She answers: "Well, two months, maybe six, probably." She cannot even guess roughly: the weather is unknown, so is how much she will sleep, and how her shoes will wear out. There is not enough data for a goal, and all you can do is set a vector. That is a vision, and its advantage is that there is no deadline pressure in it.

A goal to "walk to Moscow", though, is already real. It is about 600 kilometers (about 370 miles), 30 a day, and you can estimate how many weeks it will take. You will most likely be wrong, but the error will be small. The vision is there so you can make daily decisions. If I am walking to Lisbon and a partner calls me: "Let's launch a project in Khabarovsk" (a city in Russia's Far East), I understand it is cool, but it is not on my way. Without a vision there is a big chance I would agree and get distracted.

And a vision has the right to change. You were thinking about Lisbon, and on the road you saw Poland, Germany, France, you liked Paris and stayed. Not only the route changes, you change too, and the vision removes the tension that people dislike so much in goals.

Short goals work: two examples

In spring 2023 I was launching a sale with a plan of 12 million and set myself a very clear goal for one week. I had long been setting only a vision for the year, and I remembered again how strongly a short superhuman goal works. It gave me two things: it let me throw away every unnecessary action and focus on what could bring a result, and after a failed attempt it made me look for new solutions right away. In two days of sales, 1.5 million came in, with requests for another 3.3 million on top. I did not reach 12, and in the evening I sat and thought: is this a failure? Then I counted honestly: it made me move, I tested new products, and I knew that of five tests four usually do not take off. One more observation from that week: when a superhuman task is at stake, the risk of a 100,000 loss stops being scary, because a defeat will not affect your life much and a win will affect it a lot.

The condition for such a goal is strict: it has to be very clear, where and why, and it has to light you up, otherwise there is no point in it. I make such sprints a couple of times a year, when I need to make a transition. Working goals for a month and a quarter run all the time, while a one-week superhuman goal is rare.

The second example came from a participant in summer 2023. Her point A: about $5 on her card and roughly $1,250 in debt (100,000 rubles). She wrote down 50 things she does well and set a goal of creating 100,000 rubles (about $1,250) in 10 days. She got the amount in four days, with no social media and no mailings, just former clients remembering her, and right after that came requests for another 120,000 rubles (about $1,500). Her goal was short, specific and about an action. She did not put "pay off debt" in it, and the debts closed as a side effect.

What to set instead of yearly goals: the method

Here is the order I give participants at the end of the year, in short form.

  1. Sort your list into three columns. Everything that sounds like "have" (a car, a sum, an apartment) moves to wishes. Everything that answers "who am I becoming and where am I going" goes to vision. Only what can be done in a month or a quarter stays in goals. There is a sample of this sorting in the table above.
  2. Write the vision as images in the present tense. Write "I see how..." instead of "earn". When I turned 31, I wrote it exactly like that: "I am proud of the team I started building today", "I love my body", "I breathe freely, with no obligations". Describe income through lifestyle, meaning how you live, and treat the number as secondary.
  3. Identify the mode of the past year: ass-deep, wow or comfort. That decides whether you need a small step forward, a goal about the system, or a new direction.
  4. Set goals on a short horizon and slightly above your strength. A month, a quarter, sometimes a week. A goal is an element that improves your life now, and if you would do it effortlessly anyway, it is not a goal. It should push you to look for a solution outside the usual.
  5. Check every goal with the question "who will I have to be". If the way of being the goal demands does not appeal to you, change the method: tennis instead of the gym, a different sales channel instead of hated cold calls. Pushing harder is useless.
  6. Tie wishes to checkpoints. A vision is a 42-kilometer marathon (about 26 miles), and at each checkpoint they hand out a banana, a Snickers, water. The wish is that banana: you close the goal of the month, you get the reward, and you have enough energy for the next stretch.
  7. Check every decision against the vision. A new offer, project, partnership: is this on the way to my Lisbon, or is it Khabarovsk? Once a quarter, review both the goals and the vision itself, because you change in that time too.
7 steps instead of yearly goals1Split your list into three columnsvision, goals, wishes2Write your vision as images'I see myself…', income as lifestyle3Name last year's modeass-deep, wow or comfort4Short-lever goalsa month, a quarter, a bit beyond you5Ask 'who will I have to be'hate the path, change the method6Hang wishes on checkpointsthe banana and water of a marathon7Check decisions against visionLisbon or Khabarovsk?igorgraf.life · save this
The article's cheat sheet: step 1 takes one evening.

My rule

I have kept it since 2019: for the year I have a vision, for the month a goal, and I get the wish at a checkpoint. If a goal does not light me up this week, I rewrite it and do not scold myself for it.

FAQ

Is it bad to set goals?

No, but the way most people set them is. Goals work when they are short, measurable, and chosen because you like the path to them. Research shows specific hard goals raise results, yet narrow or inflated goals can cause risky shortcuts and kill motivation. I set goals for a month or a quarter.

Why do most goals fail?

Usually for three reasons. The goal is a wish to have something, and the road to it requires a life you do not like. Or it is set for a year and never revisited, although you changed. Or it belongs to someone else, such as a parent, a partner, or a feed, so no energy sits behind it.

Are systems better than goals?

Systems move you forward day to day, and goals give direction, so I use both. James Clear argues winners and losers share the same goals, so the system makes the difference. I agree, with one caveat: without a short measurable goal, a system often drifts, and people spend years working on themselves without one checkable step.

Can you live a good life without goals?

You can live without yearly goals, but not without direction. Without direction a person either gets stuck in comfort or starts creating problems just to feel growth again. What works is a vision a few years ahead, short goals for a month or a quarter, and the ability to enjoy what you already have.

What should you set instead of goals?

Set a vision for the year and beyond, written as images in the present tense, and short goals for a month or a quarter, slightly above your strength. Put wishes such as a car or a trip on checkpoints as rewards. Check every decision against the vision, and review both each quarter.

Igor Graf
Serial entrepreneur, 13,600+ hours on stage, mentor to 1,000+ entrepreneurs. Founder of Freeman's Alliance.
14 min read

Follow Along

Programs

Next step — pick a format

Freeman's Alliance

Build your vision and goals for your stage

In the free version of the Alliance you take a level test, and the system builds a route for your stage: which vision to hold and which short goals to set first.

Take the test
Comments
Your comment will appear after review.